Oregon campaign finance proposal crafted by business, labor groups gets first hearing

Construction at the Oregon State Capitol in Salem on Wednesday, Feb. 15, 2023. Oregon Capital Chronicle photo by Amanda Loman
February 26, 2024

Good government groups panned the proposal, which they said has too many carve-outs

By Julia Shumway, Oregon Capital Chronicle

Ahead of a Friday afternoon hearing on a last-minute effort from state representatives, labor unions and business groups to pass campaign finance limits, attendees lobbied to open curtains and let the rare February sunlight stream into the Capitol. 

“We like sunshine in government,” quipped Sen. Jeff Golden, an Ashland Democrat.

But Golden and other critics of House Bill 4024 said the proposal, hashed out by House Majority Leader Julie Fahey, Minority Leader Jeff Helfrich, labor unions and business groups, hasn’t had the kind of vetting in broad daylight it needs. Critics pointed out the bill still would allow unions and small donor committees to give hundreds of thousands of dollars to candidates, and that lawmakers popped it on the table with just two weeks left to pass bills before the legislative session ends. 

“I really don’t know how we go home, look our constituents in the eye and say we seriously reformed our campaign finance system,” Golden said. 

Oregon is one of only a handful of states with no limits on contributions to candidates, leading to eye-popping amounts spent on elections. The legislative proposal comes in response to the possibility that voters could be asked to choose between two competing campaign finance ballot measures in November, one proposed by good government groups and one backed by labor unions and progressive organizations. 

Angela Wilhelms, president of Oregon Business and Industry, the largest business group in the state, said legislative action is necessary to prevent “clutter, confusion and chaos” that could result from two competing campaign finance initiatives on the ballot. She said she understands skepticism when business and labor, which are deeply involved in elections, work together. 

“We’re asking if only for a moment we drop some of that skepticism and recognize that this proposal is a sincere attempt to get things right,” she said. 

Lawmakers have tried with varying levels of effort to address campaign finance reform in past years, but they never found a compromise.

“The labor unions have been too inflexible, business leaders have not been willing to come to the table and good government groups have not been willing to consider the practical implications of some of their positions,” said Fahey, a Democrat from Eugene. 

If limits are too low, Fahey said, it can lead to more dark money, or spending by groups that evade campaign finance laws in efforts to influence elections. Oregon doesn’t have as much dark money as other states, but lawmakers have been targeted by a D.C.-based nonprofit group that doesn’t disclose its donors. 

Carveout for unions

The proposal Fahey and Helfrich unveiled this week would prohibit candidates for state legislative offices, circuit court judges and district attorneys from receiving more than $3,300 per election — or $6,600 assuming a primary and general election — from an individual. A candidate could receive up to $5,000 per election from a political party’s committee, from a multi-candidate committee that exists to support multiple candidates and from a legislative caucus’s committee.

The proposed limits increase when it comes to labor unions: Unions and other membership organizations could give up to $16,500 per election, or $33,000 for candidates running in both primary and general election. And small donor political committees, or committees that accept up to $250 per year from individuals, could give up to $33,000 per election for every 2,500 donors to the small donor committee. That means a small donor committee with 10,000 donors could give a candidate $132,000 per election, or $264,000 for an election year with both a primary and general election. 

Unions and other membership organizations could give twice as much to candidates for governor and other statewide offices. They could also give hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of services, including hiring the equivalent of three full-time employees to work for a campaign. 

Felisa Hagins, executive director of Oregon Service Employees International Union, or SEIU, said the union gave up some of what it wanted but overall supports the proposal. 

 “There are things that our union care about deeply, like public financing, missing from this proposal,” she said. “But that’s the nature of compromise.”

House Speaker Dan Rayfield, D-Corvallis, told reporters on Thursday that he hasn’t been deeply involved in the latest efforts to rein in campaign contributions and hadn’t yet read through the proposed amendments. Any proposal needs to have bipartisan support and should include input from advocates working on various ballot measures, he said. 

Honest Elections Oregon, the group behind campaign finance reform ballot measure Initiative Petition 9, had minimal involvement, attorney Dan Meek said. The group, which is promoting its own campaign finance ballot measure with lower limits and stricter guidelines,  first received concepts for the proposal 12 days ago, sent concerns 10 days ago and participated in one two-hour video meeting before seeing the proposal two days ago.

Lawmakers haven’t shown they’re willing to consider real campaign finance reform, Meek said. 

“Folks who are elected in a system with no limits kind of like a system with no limits,” he said. “That’s what I’ve found.” 

The majority of testimony opposed the proposal. 

Patrick Starnes, who ran for governor in 2018 as the Independent Party of Oregon nominee and 2022 as a Democrat, submitted written testimony that just said “SHAME! SHAME! SHAME!” Former state Rep. Marty Wilde, a Eugene Democrat who clashed with his party over his support for campaign finance reform and independent redistricting, sent in three different letters opposing the proposal. 

“Let’s be honest here — this is a backroom deal cut in fear of a ballot measure, not an honest attempt to give voice to the 78% of the voters who voted for Measure 107,” he said, referring to a 2020 voter-approved constitutional amendment to allow campaign finance limits. “You should not be a party to the subversion of democracy. It would be better to simply get out of the way and let the voters decide.”

Julia Shumway has reported on government and politics in Iowa and Nebraska, spent time at the Bend Bulletin and most recently was a legislative reporter for the Arizona Capitol Times in Phoenix, Arizona.

Picture of Bert Etling

Bert Etling

Bert Etling is the executive editor of Ashland.news. Email him at betling@ashland.news.

Related Posts...

Level Up: Airing differences, bridging gaps

Ashland councilors Gina DuQuenne and Dylan Bloom on Wednesday gave Southern Oregon University students a lesson in how to express mutual admiration even while disagreeing. The councilors met with 15 students at Britt Hall to discuss voting, Ashland-centered topics and how to bridge the communication gap between the SOU campus and Ashland.

Read More »

Portion of Walker Avenue closed Friday and Monday for roadwork

A quarter-mile stretch of Walker Avenue between the railroad tracks and East Main Street will be closed Friday, Oct. 11, and Monday, Oct. 14, so roadwork can be done,the city of Ashland announced Thursday. Profiling and grinding work is planned for 7 a.m. to 5 p.m. Friday, while overlay is set to be laid down Monday from 6 a.m. to 7 p.m

Read More »

Q&A with Ashland City Council candidates Jeff Dahle and Kelly Marcotulli  

For the upcoming Ashland City Council election, all candidates were contacted by Ashland.news for interviews. All who responded were asked the same six questions. Answers from candidates competing for the same position have been paired together. In this, is the first of three articles on contested council seats, we hear from Kelly Marcotulli and Jeff Dahle, candidates for council Position 2.

Read More »

Our Sponsors

Southern Oregon PBS A New SOPBS Series Energy Horizons
ScienceWorks Museum Monster Ball Ashland Oregon
Literary Arts Portland Book Festival Portland Oregon

Latest posts

Level Up: Airing differences, bridging gaps

Ashland councilors Gina DuQuenne and Dylan Bloom on Wednesday gave Southern Oregon University students a lesson in how to express mutual admiration even while disagreeing. The councilors met with 15 students at Britt Hall to discuss voting, Ashland-centered topics and how to bridge the communication gap between the SOU campus and Ashland.

Read More >

Crossword: First Settlers

This week’s crossword recognizes Indigenous Peoples’ Day. Solve it directly in the article or download a PDF to print. Next week’s crossword: “OSF’s Secret Season.” More crosswords under the Culture menu.

Read More >

Review: ‘Witch’ an unsettling story

Review: “Witch,” isn’t exactly a Halloween piece per se, but it is unsettling. And if you like stories that are distinctive, disturbing yet thought-provoking, this might be for you. This is a play where no one is as they seem; where our motives and desires can give rise to good or evil.

Read More >

Photojournalism tips from a professional

Bob Palermini, professional photographer, will give a presentation about photojournalism at the Southern Oregon Photographic Association meeting on October 15 in Medford. He studied photojournalism in college and has been a photographer for Ashland.news since shortly after it debuted in January 2022.

Read More >

Our Sponsors

Ashland Parks and Recreation Ashland Oregon
City of Ashland Public Notice Ashland Oregon
Ashland.news First Edition and Holiday Events Guide 2024 Ashland Oregon

Explore More...

Pam Hammond beamed earlier this week while talking about new plans in store for downtown Ashland’s Paddington Station sister stores, The Jewel Box and Inspired By Oregon, which are consolidating and moving into the prominent Fortmiller building across the street.
Ashland councilors Gina DuQuenne and Dylan Bloom on Wednesday gave Southern Oregon University students a lesson in how to express mutual admiration even while disagreeing. The councilors met with 15 students at Britt Hall to discuss voting, Ashland-centered topics and how to bridge the communication gap between the SOU campus and Ashland.
This week's crossword recognizes Indigenous Peoples' Day. Solve it directly in the article or download a PDF to print. Next week's crossword: "OSF's Secret Season." More crosswords under the Culture menu.
Review: "Witch," isn’t exactly a Halloween piece per se, but it is unsettling. And if you like stories that are distinctive, disturbing yet thought-provoking, this might be for you. This is a play where no one is as they seem; where our motives and desires can give rise to good or evil.
Bob Palermini, professional photographer, will give a presentation about photojournalism at the Southern Oregon Photographic Association meeting on October 15 in Medford. He studied photojournalism in college and has been a photographer for Ashland.news since shortly after it debuted in January 2022.
ashland.news logo

Subscribe to the newsletter and get local news sent directly to your inbox.

(It’s free)

Don't Miss Our Top Stories

Get our newsletter delivered to your inbox three times a week.
It’s FREE and you can cancel anytime.