Viewpoint: A closer look at the Grand Terrace proposal

The site plan for the Grand Terrace project off Highway 99 just north of Ashland.
August 21, 2023

Rogue Advocates member says Ashland.news missed some points in latest story on the proposed housing project and cites ‘the systematic coddling of developers’ by the city

By Craig Anderson

Regarding the Aug. 16 article “Ashland Planning Commission approves Grand Terrace development for the third time”:

Thank you for covering this important issue. Your reporter did a good job summarizing some of the complex legal issues involved. However, there were a few inaccuracies that could use clarification.

First, the Planning Commission was not asked to “approve (the annexation) for a third time” at its Aug. 8 meeting. Rather, as a result of the Land Use Board of Appeals’ (LUBA’s) May 2023 remand, the City of Ashland must respond to two specific legal issues in order for its December 2022 approval to be affirmed. If the City of Ashland isn’t able to successfully respond to the two issues, the approval will be reversed, necessitating a third application to come before the Planning Commission and the council.

Of the two issues remanded back to the city, one requires the city to explain how, given Ashland’s minimum square footage requirements for affordable one-bedroom and studio units of 500 and 350 square feet, respectively, the city approved 499- and 250-square foot units. Although the 1-square-foot difference (499 versus 500) for one-bedroom units is certainly negligible, the 100-square-foot difference (250 versus 350) for studio units is definitely not.

Your article mentioned only the one-bedroom units. The Grand Terrace application materials indicate that 30 of the 38 affordable units would be studio units. So, based on the city’s approval, nearly 80% of affordable housing occupants would be crammed into substandard 250-square-foot apartments in the bottom floor of a three-story building that’s dug into the side of a hill, permitting daylight to only one side of the studio units.

In contrast, the two upper floors — designated for “luxury” market-rate occupancy — would be above ground, with balconies facing Grizzly Peak to the east and views of mountains to the west. This type of “ghettoization” of affordable units was prohibited by our code up until immediately before the city’s first approval of Grand Terrace in December 2020.

Other changes — including reducing the number of required affordable units, altering System Development Charge payment terms, and lowering the review standards for bicycle and pedestrian safety — were similarly approved by the council in order to make things easier, and less costly, for Grand Terrace’s developer.

Which brings us to the main point overlooked in your article: The systematic violation of development regulations by the City of Ashland to the point of ignoring affordable housing requirements as well as basic public safety issues, as exemplified by LUBA’s reversal and remand of two separate approvals. Ashland’s housing needs are well-defined. “Luxury” market-rate and substandard “affordable” apartments — as proposed by the developer of Grand Terrace — don’t begin to address those needs, particularly given the extreme difficulty of ingress and egress on a 45-mph stretch of highway with poor visibility.

Why are we rewriting — and ignoring — our laws in an effort to approve something that doesn’t meet our needs?

Craig Anderson is a former transportation and land use planner and member of Rogue Advocates.

Ashland.news welcomes Viewpoint submissions of 500-700 words. Viewpoints may be emailed to [email protected] or submitted through the “Article Submission Form” link at the bottom right corner of the home page. Please include your name and city of residence with your Viewpoint (which will be published) and, in case we have a question, your contact information (which won’t be published unless you say it’s OK).

Nov. 14, 2024: Minor edit made to one paragraph.

Picture of Jim

Jim

Related Posts...

Viewpoint: V was for victory

Paul R. Huard: On this day, which might be the last day during your life that anyone raises the importance of VE Day to you, remember that they died for you. They died so the United States — and the world — would be governed by the rule of law and the consent of the people, not by strongmen and oligarchs

Read More »

Viewpoint: Project 25, the enemy within

Michael O’Looney: When he was campaigning, Trump tried to disassociate himself from Project 25, claiming he had nothing to do with it, that some of its ideas were “absolutely ridiculous and abysmal.” But he has been complicit in implementing Project 25’s playbook to the letter.

Read More »

Viewpoint: The Supreme Court holds the Trump card

Robert Delsman: If Trump/the administration defies the district court’s order as affirmed 9-0 by the Supreme Court in the Abrego Garcia case or any other case, the issue before the court will (be) whether defying the legitimate order of a coequal branch of government is an exercise of core presidential powers. The answer to that question must be a resounding “No,” because the alternative would be the utter collapse of our constitutional order and the institution of a dictatorship.

Read More »

Our Sponsors

Ashland Climate Collaborative Sreets for Everyone Ashland Oregon
Southern Oregon Repertory Singers SOU Music Recital Hall Ashland Oregon
ScienceWorks Hands-on Museum Summer Camp Ashland Oregon

Latest posts

Crossword: Rock Around the Clock

This week’s crossword: 4 times for music (can you spot a local business?). Solve it directly in the article or download a PDF to print. Next Friday’s crossword: “Grin and Bear It #02.” More crosswords under the Culture menu.

Read More >

Our Sponsors

Conscious Design Build Ashland Oregon
Southern Oregon Summer Camps and Activities Directory Ashland Medford Oregon
Ashland Community Composting Ashland Oregon
City of Ashland Public Notice Ashland Oregon

Explore More...

This summer, a small group of local high school students will have the opportunity to learn about restoration of the Southern Oregon landscape and wildfire prevention.
Herbert Rothschild: Trump is only the latest Republican who has told working-class white males that they lost their power because women and especially peoples of color have been given advantages they didn’t have.
This week's crossword: 4 times for music (can you spot a local business?). Solve it directly in the article or download a PDF to print. Next Friday's crossword: "Grin and Bear It #02." More crosswords under the Culture menu.
The Ashland Citizens’ Budget Committee Wednesday recommended a $373 million biennial city budget that avoids drastic cuts to parks and throws a lifeline to a preschool grant program.
ashland.news logo

Subscribe to the newsletter and get local news sent directly to your inbox.

(It’s free)

Don't Miss Our Top Stories

Get our newsletter delivered to your inbox three times a week.
It’s FREE and you can cancel anytime.