Viewpoint: Protect homeowners and pets, not destructive deer

A doe and two fawns graze near Palmer Road in Ashland in July 2022. Ashland.news photo by Holly Dillemuth
June 26, 2024

City policy safeguards Ashland’s destructive deer, which don’t just go after dogs; they take out tens of thousands of dollars in landscaping

By Conde Cox

Our community should address the negative impact that our city policies to protect our destructive urban deer population are imposing on all of us. 

Not only are these sickly non-wild deer a physical threat to our household pets, as Ashland.news recently reported, but also these deer also destroy tens of thousands of dollars worth of landscaping in our city every year. Indeed, many local citizens are forced to put up large unattractive fencing around their yards, solely to keep these destructive deer off of their landscaping.

Not wild

We are not dealing here with wild animals these deer in our town are in fact obviously sickly, sometimes aggressive and often destructive. They would not last five minutes in a true wilderness environment precisely because they are sick, not wilderness creatures, and are unable to defend for themselves except when attacking our pets and our residential landscaping.

These deer are protected by our local law enforcement from harvesting and from relocation. I know this because when I called the city to ask (sarcastically) who was going to reimburse me for the thousands of dollars in vet bills that I incurred as result of one of these sickly urban deer attacking my small dog, I was reminded that these deer are protected from harvests or removal under our city ordinances. 

Policies need to change

This city urban deer policy, which I believe is backed up by Oregon Department of Fish & Wildlife policy, needs to change. That’s especially important given the upcoming election ballot item relating to a city proposal to borrow $75 million for a new Mount Ashland watershed Ashland drinking water reservoir, because a large percentage of the water projected to be needed by our residents in the future is strictly for irrigation of our domestic plants and residential landscaping. 

Growing gardens, feeding deer

Yet, we protect the urban sickly deer population in our town that are every day destroying our landscaping! Why incur huge debt to supply our residents with plenty of future irrigation water while simultaneously protecting the urban deer that are destroying our landscaping and, sometimes, our pets?

And I am sure that there are additional costs incurred every year by some local residents for motor vehicle repair caused by street collisions with these sickly, wandering, destructive creatures.

In short, why borrow $75 million for water for future landscaping that these deer will largely destroy anyway? And these same deer are also threatening and injuring our pets. 

We need a fresh look at our city policies that protect our sickly destructive urban non-wild deer population. 

There is no need to borrow tens of millions of dollars to build up new city water reserves that will be largely used to quench the thirst of our landscape plants, so long as we continue with policies that protect these destructive deer that have the effect of largely nullifying the value of all that additional water!

Conde Cox is an Ashland attorney.

Picture of Jim

Jim

Don't Drown Ashland in Debt PAC 23909

Related Posts...

Viewpoint: Why I oppose Measure 15-234

Dean Silver: I organized the petition drive against Resolution 2024-05 in March. I was shocked that the City Council would authorize up to $75 million of debt at 4.77% for 35 years without referring the question to the people who would be paying — the voters. With the terms presented, that debt could result in over $150 million of total cost with interest.

Read More »

Viewpoint: What Ashland voters want City Council candidates to talk about

Lorrie Kaplan: What do you want Ashland City Council candidates to be talking about as they compete for votes? That’s the question included in a “Citizens Agenda” poll available through every edition of the Ashland.news e-newsletter beginning in August. The poll closed Sept. 20. Ashland.news received 219 responses, many showing great care and thoughtfulness.

Read More »

Viewpoint: Don’t fence us out, Ashland schools, you need us

Sean F. McEnroe: In 2020 during the COVID shutdown, construction fences and flood lighting started going up around Ashland’s neighborhood schools. They never came down. What appeared to be temporary barriers became permanent ones, locking off spaces which had served as de facto public parks for generations.

Read More »

Our Sponsors

Don't Drown Ashland in Debt PAC 23909
Literary Arts Portland Book Festival Portland Oregon
Conscious Design Build Ashland Oregon

Latest posts

Crossword: Fun(d)raising #01

Crossword about different ways to support Ashland.news. Solve it directly in the article or download a PDF to print. Next week’s crossword: “Oregon-e Rogue #02.” More crosswords under the Culture menu.

Read More >

Phantasms on parade: Ashland’s got souls — lots of them

Thousands of costumed characters packed downtown Ashland on Thursday afternoon, making their along Main Street from Ashland Public Library to Ashland Plaza for the Ashland Chamber of Commerce’s Children’s Halloween Parade, which annually draws large numbers of children of all ages. According to one officer, it was the most people he’s seen in years.

Read More >

Future uncertain for Ashland’s severe weather shelter at 2200 Ashland St.

As the weather chills, the city of Ashland continues to wrestle with how to best operate its severe weather shelter in and plan the overall future of its building at 2200 Ashland St. While the city’s threshold for calling the severe weather shelter in winter is 32 degrees, there is some room for variation depending on accompanying weather conditions, duration of conditions and available resources, Ashland City Manager Sabrina Cotta said Wednesday.

Read More >

Our Sponsors

Pronto Printing Ashland Medford Oregon
City of Ashland Public Notice Ashland Oregon
Ashland.news House Ad

Explore More...

Crossword about different ways to support Ashland.news. Solve it directly in the article or download a PDF to print. Next week's crossword: "Oregon-e Rogue #02." More crosswords under the Culture menu.
Thousands of costumed characters packed downtown Ashland on Thursday afternoon, making their along Main Street from Ashland Public Library to Ashland Plaza for the Ashland Chamber of Commerce's Children’s Halloween Parade, which annually draws large numbers of children of all ages. According to one officer, it was the most people he’s seen in years.
As the weather chills, the city of Ashland continues to wrestle with how to best operate its severe weather shelter in and plan the overall future of its building at 2200 Ashland St. While the city’s threshold for calling the severe weather shelter in winter is 32 degrees, there is some room for variation depending on accompanying weather conditions, duration of conditions and available resources, Ashland City Manager Sabrina Cotta said Wednesday.
After the AIFF opened the doors to their newly remodeled center, the COVID-19 pandemic hit, leading the festival to go virtual. Now, the AIFF is up and running with their first in person event to be held since 2019.
Herbert Rothschild: The sanctions we impose on other countries have never achieved our stated aims — usually regime change. They have succeeded in inflicting suffering and death on the resident populations.
ashland.news logo

Subscribe to the newsletter and get local news sent directly to your inbox.

(It’s free)

Don't Miss Our Top Stories

Get our newsletter delivered to your inbox three times a week.
It’s FREE and you can cancel anytime.