Fire District 5, union OK reduced staffing limits to help cover more stations

Jackson County Fire District 5 board members, from left, John Karns, Greg Costanzo, Sam Pare-Miller and Chris Luz at Tuesday's meeting. Rogue Valley Times photo by Buffy Pollock
March 12, 2025

Two personnel will be allowed to respond in engine or other apparatus, down from three; town hall set for Saturday at Neil Creek Station No. 4 outside Ashland

By Buffy Pollock, Rogue Valley Times

Jackson County Fire District 5 officials and union members reached an agreement Tuesday for reduced staffing minimums on fire engines and other apparatus to better distribute service coverage during an ongoing staffing struggle.

District officials vowed Tuesday that the staffing change would be short-lived — hopefully only until the end of 2025, if FD5 has the opportunity to overcome financial instability and rebuild its ranks.

Brady Graham, president of the International Association of Fire Fighters Local 2596, said at a meeting Tuesday night at Fire District 5 Station No. 5 outside Talent that a boost in confidence in district leadership enabled members to OK the temporary change.

The district has weathered a series of storms that began last February when Graham stood during a board meeting to declare a loss in confidence in Chief Charles Hanley.

He alleged there was unacceptable treatment of employees by top-level brass, as well as a staffing crisis that threatened the safety of firefighters and the public.

The past year was marked by investigations, the termination of Hanley, board resignations and reappointments, financial woes and criminal investigations.

A third-party investigation last year revealed Hanley permitted and contributed to a culture of alleged sexual harassment and misconduct that included lewd behavior from district brass, Hanley screaming at an employee and the chief changing test scores during a promotion process.

Last summer, district officials began to pursue a contract for administrative support from surrounding districts. Jackson County Fire 3 took over leadership of District 5 on Jan. 1, providing administrative and other services.

Station No. 4 near Emigrant Lake outside Ashland has been frequently browned out — not staffed — for much of the past year, providing a bone of contention for FD5 patrons and highlighting the staffing crisis.

The biggest change approved Tuesday through a Memorandum of Understanding OK’d by the union is to allow a minimum of two firefighters on any engine or other apparatus during a call.

The previous minimum was three personnel, which meant if five people were on a shift, only one engine or other apparatus could respond. Under the new agreement, if five people are on shift, three firefighters could staff one station and two could staff another.

“There will be a minimum of five personnel on duty per day,” Hussey told the Rogue Valley Times, adding, “When we’re less than five, we would call someone back (to the station).

“When we’re at five, we’d staff one engine of three (firefighters) and one with two. Anytime we have more than five, it would allow us to provide staffing of two (firefighters) on each of three engines” at stations 3, 4 and 5.

Chief Aaron Bustard walks through the doors of Jackson County Fire District No. 5 Station No. 4 off Neil Creek Road in Ashland near Emigrant Lake in the fall of 2024. Rogue Valley Times photo by Andy Atkinson

The new staffing rules are set to go into effect Saturday, March 15.

Graham said the union felt a sense of confidence in the new leadership and trusted Hussey to look out for employees.

A recent loss of eight employees, funded through a nonrenewable “SAFER” grant, through FEMA, had made the staffing struggle even harder.

“The selling factor in this was for us to make a kind of massive concession on our side to speed up the rebuilding process, and hopefully we can get back to appropriate staffing sooner than if we were just to nickel and dime things and to draw it out longer,” Graham said Tuesday. “It definitely stings. … It hurts safety. It hurts everything. But it’s better than losing your job, and so it’s an appropriate sacrifice for us right now.”

Hussey said he felt optimistic about changes made since Jan. 1.

“I’m feeling really good about the progress that’s been made, the relationships that are being built, and I recognize the workforce needs to learn to trust administration,” he said. “We’re putting our best foot forward and I feel like between the (union) and the administration, there’s unity in a path forward.”

Hussey announced the staffing agreement to the board and audience members during the Tuesday meeting and provided financial updates and other information.

A town hall is set for 11 a.m. Saturday at Station 4, 40 Neil Creek Road, off South Pacific Highway, where district officials will give the community an update on FD5 operations.

Reach reporter Buffy Pollock at 458-488-2029 or [email protected]. Follow her on Twitter @orwritergal. This story first appeared in the Rogue Valley Times.

Picture of Bert Etling

Bert Etling

Bert Etling is the executive editor of Ashland.news. Email him at [email protected].
Siskiyou Woodcraft Guild Harvest Show of fine woodworking OSF Hay-Patton Rehearsal Center across from Ashland Springs Hotel Ashland Oregon

Related Posts...

Asbestos found at Lincoln School to delay renovations

An estimate for the cost to abate asbestos found in the shuttered Lincoln School recently should be available as early as sometime this week, according to Steve Mitzel, operations director for Ashland School District. The cost to remove asbestos would be separate from the as yet-unknown cost for structural repair.

Read More »

Our Sponsors

ScienceWorks Hands-on Museum Subterranean Science In the Dark Ashland Oregon
Camelot Theatre Hansel and Gretel Talent Oregon
Siskiyou Woodcraft Guild Harvest Show of fine woodworking OSF Hay-Patton Rehearsal Center across from Ashland Springs Hotel Ashland Oregon

Latest posts

Mini Crossword #01

A mini (5 x 5) crossword debuts this week; it’s a smaller, more approachable puzzle for beginning solvers; an early mid-week (Tuesday) appetizer for cruciverbalists before the full-size Friday crossword; bespoke & human-crafted, usually with two or more local seed words or names; free for everyone — thanks to your support of Ashland.news. Solve the mini in your browser or download and print. More info about minis: FAQ: Mini. Next Friday’s crossword: Yule Be Puzzled #01.

Read More >

Asbestos found at Lincoln School to delay renovations

An estimate for the cost to abate asbestos found in the shuttered Lincoln School recently should be available as early as sometime this week, according to Steve Mitzel, operations director for Ashland School District. The cost to remove asbestos would be separate from the as yet-unknown cost for structural repair.

Read More >

Our Sponsors

Ashland Community Composting Ashland Oregon
Ashland Food Project Building Community Ashland Oregon
Literary Arts The Moth Arlene Schnitzer Concert Hall Portland Oregon
Conscious Design Build Ashland Oregon
Ashland Climate Collaborative Sreets for Everyone Ashland Oregon

Explore More...

The Oregon Legislature is meeting this week to consider some major cuts to current spending levels as a large revenue deficit looms. That’s because the state’s tax code automatically replicates new federal tax cuts, including ones passed by Congressional Republicans this summer that will reduce state revenue
Michael O'Looney: Trump and the Texas Legislature are responsible for a partisan power grab that has unleashed bitterness and partisan vindictiveness, all in an effort to subvert an electoral system for partisan ends.
Councilor Bob Kaplan: While the cost of delivering kilowatt-hours to our homes has risen, Ashland Electric has been able to hold our rates steady with just one increase of 5.1% in 2021. I’m sorry to say we’re due for an increase, but fortunately it’s not likely to match recent increases elsewhere.
A mini (5 x 5) crossword debuts this week; it's a smaller, more approachable puzzle for beginning solvers; an early mid-week (Tuesday) appetizer for cruciverbalists before the full-size Friday crossword; bespoke & human-crafted, usually with two or more local seed words or names; free for everyone -- thanks to your support of Ashland.news. Solve the mini in your browser or download and print. More info about minis: FAQ: Mini. Next Friday's crossword: Yule Be Puzzled #01.
An estimate for the cost to abate asbestos found in the shuttered Lincoln School recently should be available as early as sometime this week, according to Steve Mitzel, operations director for Ashland School District. The cost to remove asbestos would be separate from the as yet-unknown cost for structural repair.

Don't Miss Our Top Stories

Get our newsletter delivered to your inbox three times a week.
It’s FREE and you can cancel anytime.

ashland.news logo

Subscribe to the newsletter and get local news sent directly to your inbox.

(It’s free)