Ask Strider: Advice for big brothers

Boys and pups have a lot in common. Image by Joshua Choate from Pixabay
October 1, 2025

Bringing up puppies isn’t that different from bringing up boys

By Strider the Dog

Dear Strider,

I’m thinking you can help me here, as a big dog who’s had to mentor pups. I have a younger brother. As his older brother, I really feel responsible, since it’s only him, my mom, and me. So I worry about him a lot.

What hints do you have for me on how to help bring him up right? I figure bringing up puppies has something to say for me.

Concerned Older Brother

Dear Concerned,

Wow, are your brother and your mom lucky to have you in the family! As a matter of fact, I do have some advice for you, based on my experience being the elder dog when we bring puppies into the pack.

Strider the Dog

Here are the basics:

  1. Be honest: Never sneak out on a puppy. Always tell him when you’re going out, for how long, and when you’re hoping to be back.
  2. Be firm but kind: If you criticize a puppy unfairly, remember to apologize. Don’t try to pretend it didn’t happen. And don’t ever punish harshly. Mild correction, just a nip and a growl, is better. Puppies mean to do right, and guidance for how to do that is best.
  3.  Be a good role model: Teach your puppy by example, especially in showing that standing up for those weaker than himself will make him a nobler dog.
  4. Be a peaceful big dog: Teach him that violence in anything but self-defense is not a good form of problem solving, and that, if possible, it’s always better to walk away from a fight.

I think that about covers it. Oh, also share your treats with him, and don’t mind if he dawdles behind you on walks.

Hope that helps.

Dear Strider,

My dog is very affectionate with everyone, except people who wear hats! When he sees one of those, he just goes crazy. It’s very embarrassing, especially if I don’t notice a hat wearer is coming up behind us when we’re out on a walk. The barking and lunging are very unnerving.

As a dog, do you have any idea what causes this? And what, if anything, can be done to fix it?

Worried Dog Owner

Dear Worried,

Your dog probably had a bad experience in the past with a hat-wearing person, and they get reminded of it when someone looks like the trauma causing perp. I had a close friend who couldn’t help but go crazy barking whenever he saw a firefighter! Since firefighters are our friends, I asked him what was going on. It turned out firefighters wear the same kinds of jumpsuits as they wear in animal control. He’d gotten picked up by one of those animal control guys and thrown in a shelter, and even though he had been since adopted into a great family, those jumpsuits still gave him a chill.

He got over it eventually on his own, with his family reassuring him every time that nothing bad was going to happen when a jumpsuit appeared. You could try giving your dog treats and speaking soothingly to him every time he reacts. But if that doesn’t work, maybe confer with a good dog trainer? Companion Canine is an excellent choice, but there are others around the Rogue Valley you could check out.

In the meantime, good luck!

Got questions? Got answers? No matter what your thoughts, our advice columnist loves hearing them, one and all. Just email [email protected].

Picture of Tod

Tod

Southern Oregon Subaru Medford Oregon

Related Posts...

Ask Strider: Act. Relax. Repeat.

Ask Strider: Our advice columnist has soothing counsel for an activist worried they’re not doing all they can. And he finds similarity between a wife’s problem with her husband and his own with a puppy who doesn’t want to bother finding his own bone.

Read More »

Ask Strider: You can’t always get what you want

Ask Strider: There’s a tough question this column about compromise in a marriage, as well as praise from another reader for crossword editor Steve Weyer’s Canine Crossword created just for Strider and his friends. For our advice columnist, it’s all good.

Read More »

Ask Strider: Looking for a smile

Ask Strider: A reader wants to bring a smile to his wife’s face, and our advice columnist tackles this puzzle by suggesting a crossword invented by puzzle editor Steve Weyer just for Strider. What could be better?

Read More »

Our Sponsors

Camelot Theatre Hansel and Gretel Talent Oregon
Siskiyou Woodcraft Guild Harvest Show of fine woodworking OSF Hay-Patton Rehearsal Center across from Ashland Springs Hotel Ashland Oregon
Paddinton Station Holiday Open House Ashland Oregon

Latest posts

Crossword: Canine Capers #03

This week’s theme: canine-related phrases about paper and journalism for Strider, especially apropos for end-of-year fund raising. Solve it in your browser or download and print. This is the 100th word puzzle in Ashland.news since Oh, Deer! #01 debuted on Feb. 2, 2024! Next Friday’s crossword: Turkish Delights #03. Next Tuesday, a new, smaller mid-week feature debuts: Mini #01.

Read More >

Our Sponsors

Ashland Community Composting Ashland Oregon
Siskiyou School's Winter Faire Festival and Holiday Market Ashland Oregon
Conscious Design Build Ashland Oregon
Literary Arts The Moth Arlene Schnitzer Concert Hall Portland Oregon
Pronto Printing Ashland Medford Southern Oregon

Explore More...

As of Nov. 3, Ashland Community Food Bank has a new director at the reins. Catie Mahoney will serve in the role with guidance from outgoing director Amey Broeker, who will officially retire on Dec. 31 after serving in the food bank role since 2022.
The Ashland City Council will review a proposal from a potential provider to oversee its extreme weather shelter during its regular business meeting on Tuesday, Nov. 18.
The Ashland Independent Film Festival has added a second screening showcasing Indigenous filmmakers on Sunday, Nov. 23.
Three and a half years into the war with Russia, Ashland violinist and longtime music teacher Faina Podolnaya is still finding ways to help Ukrainian refugees.
Herbert Rothschild: As the number of ads in The New Yorker has shrunk, it seems as if the wealth of its readership has concentrated, just as one might concentrate the flavor of a sauce by reducing it on the stovetop.

Don't Miss Our Top Stories

Get our newsletter delivered to your inbox three times a week.
It’s FREE and you can cancel anytime.

ashland.news logo

Subscribe to the newsletter and get local news sent directly to your inbox.

(It’s free)